±q¿ïÁ|¨î«×­±½×¥ßªk°|®Ä¯à¤§§ïµ½

§õ¾Ëºa

 

«e¨¥

¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¾Ë¬FÅé¨î¦b¥xÆW¹ê¦æ¡A­ì¥»´N¦³¥¿·í©Ê(Legitimacy)©M¾A·í©Ê(Propriety)ªº°ÝÃD¡C©Ò¿×¥¿·í©Ê¬O«ü¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¾Ëªk¡v¦b«n¨Ê¨î©w®É¡A¥xÆW©|¬O¤é¥»ªº´Þ¥Á¦a¡A¦Ó¤£¬O¤¤µØ¥Á°êªº»â¤g¡A·íµM¤]¨S¦³¨ã¦³¥¿·í©Êªº¥xÆW¨î¾Ë¥Nªí°Ñ»P¡C¹ï¥xÆW¦Ó¨¥¡A¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¾Ëªk¡v¥»½è¤W¬O¤@³¡¥~°êªº¾Ëªk¡A²@µL¥¿·í©Ê¥i¨¥¡C©Ò¿×¾A·í©Ê¬O«ü¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¾Ëªk¡v¬O¥H·í®É¾ã­Ó¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¡v©Ò²Îªvªº¦a°Ï(¥]¬A¤¤°ê¤j³°¦U¬Ù¡B»X¥j¡B©M¦èÂáA¦ý¤£¥]¬A¥xÆW)¬°¥»¦Ó¨î©w¡A¨Ò¦p¤¤¥¡¥Á·N¥Nªí(°ê¥N¡B¥ß©e¡B©MºÊ©e)ªº¿ïÁ|´N¬O«Ü©úÅ㪺¨Ò¤l¡C

°£¦¹¤§¥~¡A¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¾Ëªk¡v¦³Ãö¬F©²Åé¨îªº³]­p¤]¦³«Ü¦h°ÝÃD¡C³o¨Ç°ÝÃD©TµM¤]¦³¾ÇªÌÆg¬ü¬°³Ç¥Xªº³Ð§@¡A¨Ò¦p©Ò¿×¬FÅv»PªvÅvªº¹º¤À¡B¤­Åvªº¤À¥ß¡BÁ`²Î¨î»P¤º»Õ¨îªº²V¦Xµ¥µ¥¡A³o¨Ç¡u³Ç¥Xªº³Ð§@¡v¦b¥xÆW¶i¤J¥Á¥D¤Æ¤§«á¤@¤@Åã²{¥¦­Ìªº¤ò¯f¡A¦b¹L¥h¤Q¦~ªº¾Ë¬F§ï­²¤¤¡A¤]¦¨¬°³Q§ï­²(­×¾Ë)ªº¹ï¶H¡C

·í¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¡v¬F©²±q¤j³°¾E¥x¤§«á¡A¦³»·¨£ªº¬Fªv»â¾É¤H¦­´NÀ³¸Ó¼o°£©Î­áµ²¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¾Ëªk¡v¡A¥t¥~¨î©w¤@³¡¥H¥xÆW¬°¥»¦ìªº¾Ëªk¦b¥xÆW¹ê¦æ¡C¥i¬O°õ¬Fªº°ê¥ÁÄÒ¬F©²¬°ºûÅ@©Ò¿×ªº¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¡vªk²Î¡Aµw¬O¥H¡u°Ê­û·`¶Ã®É´ÁÁ{®É±ø´Ú¡v©M¤jªk©x·|ijªº¸ÑÄÀ¨ÓÀ³¹ï¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¡v¾Ëªk¦b¥xÆW¹ê¦æªº§x¹Ò¡A¨Ã¥Î§ÙÄY«ÂÅv¨î«×¨ÓÂíÀ£¤H¥Áªº¤Ï§Ü¡C³oºØ¤£¥¿·í¡B¤£¦X²zªºÀ³¹ï¤è¦¡·íµM¤£¬Oªø¤[¤§­p¡A¦]¦¹¦b¤@¤E¤E¡³¦~¥Nªì´Á¥xÆWÂ૬¬°¥Á¥DÅé¨î®É¡A¾Ë¬F¦M¾÷°¨¤WÃzµo¥X¨Ó¡C

­±¹ï¾Ë¬F¦M¾÷¡A¦b³¥¥D±i¥H¥xÆW¬°¥»¨î©w¤@³¡·s¾Ëªk¡A°õ¬Fªº°ê¥ÁÄÒ°í«ù¥H¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¡v¾Ëªk¬°¥»­×¾Ë¡C¤W­±´£¨ì¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¡v¾Ëªk½T¹ê¬O¦³³\¦h°ÝÃD¡C¤»¦¸ªº­×¾Ë¡A©TµM§ïµ½¨ä¤¤¤@¨Ç°ÝÃD¡A¨Ò¦p±N¹ê»Ú¤W¤w«D¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¡v²Îªv½d³òªº¤¤°ê¤j³°±Æ°£¦b¾Ëªk¾A¥Îªº½d³ò¤§¥~¡A¨Ï¾Ëªk¦^Âk¨ì»P¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¡v²Îªv½d³ò¬Û²Åªº²{¹ê¡A¤S¦p±N°ê¥Á¤j·|µê¯Å¤Æµ¥µ¥¡C

¦ý¤»¦¸ªº­×¾Ë¡A¨C¦¸­×¾Ë³£¬O°w¹ï·í®Éªº¬Fªv°ÝÃD´M¨D§Y®Éªº¸Ñ¨M¿ìªk¡A¨Ã¥¼¥H¾Ë¬F­ì²z¬°³Ì°ªªº«ü¾É­ì«h¡A°µ¦³¨t²Îªº³v¨B­×¾Ë¡A©ÎªÌ¬O¦b´£¥X¸Ñ¨M¿ìªk®É­ÝÅU¨ì¥²­nªº°t®M³]­p¡C¦]¦¹¡A­×¾Ë¤£¦ý¥¼¨Ï¤W­z¦³Ãö¬F©²Åé¨î³]­pªº°ÝÃD¦³©Ò§ïµ½¡A¤Ï¦Ó»s³y¤F³\¦h·sªº°ÝÃD¡C¨Ò¦pÁ`²Î§ï¥Ñ¤H¥Áª½¿ï¡A¦æ¬F°|ªø§ï¥ÑÁ`²Î¥ô©RµL¶·¸g¥ßªk°|ªº¦P·N¡A­×¾Ë¥D¾ÉÅv²¾¨ì¥ßªk°|µ¥µ¥¡A³£¨S¦³°t®M¾÷¨î¡A¨Ï¾ã­Ó¤¤¥¡¬F©²ªºÅé¨î©M¦U³¡ªùªºÅv³d©M¤¬°ÊÃö«YÅܦ¨§ó¥[½ÆÂø©M¼Ò½k¡C³o¬O³y¦¨·í«eªº³\¦h¬Fªv¦M¾÷ªº¤@­Ó¥D­n­ì¦]¡C

¥ßªk°|ªº°ÝÃD­ì¥»´N«Ü¦h¡A±`³Q´£¥Xªº°ÝÃD¦³¥ßªk©e­û­Ó¤Hªº¯À½è¤Ó®t¡A½è¸ß¨î«×¤£°·¥þ¡A¥ßªkÅv(°ê·|Åv)³Q¤Á³Î¡B²Õ´(¦p©e­û¨î«×)¤£°·¥þ¡B§U²z©M¹õ¹±¨î«×¥¼«Ø¥ß¡B¯Ê¥F°ê·|­Û²z¡B¬FÄÒ¬£»ÖªL¥ß¡B¥\¯à¤£¹üµ¥µ¥¡C¤»¦¸­×¾Ë¹ï¥ßªk°|ªº³W©w°µ¤F¬Û·í¤j´T«×ªº­×§ï¡A³Ì­«­n¬O¬O¦³Ãö¥ß©eªº¿ïÁ|¡B¥ßªk°|ªºÂ¾Åv¡A©M¥ßªk°|»P¦æ¬F°|ªºÅv³dÃö«Y¡C¥ßªk©e­ûªº¿ïÁ|·íµM¬O¨Ì¾Ú¾Ëªk¡A¦]¦¹½×¥ß©e¿ïÁ|¨î«×ªº§ï­²¥²¥ý±q¾ËªkµÛ¤â¡C¥ßªk©e­ûªº¯À½è¤Ó®t»P¥ßªk©e­ûªº¿ïÁ|¨î«×ªº¤£¨}¦³±K¤ÁªºÃö«Y¡A¥»¤åªº¥Øªº¦b±´°Q­×¾Ë«áªº¥ßªk°|¥ßªk©e­û¿ïÁ|¨î«×ªº°ÝÃD¥H¤Î§ï­²ªº¤è¦V¡C

 

¥ßªk©e­ûªº²£¥Í

 

¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¾Ëªk¡v­ì¤å³W©w¡A¥ßªk©e­û¥Ñ¦U¬Ù¡Bª½ÁÒ¥«(¤T¦Ê¸U¥H¤UªÌ¤­¤H¡A¨Cº¡¤@¦Ê¸U¤H¼W¥[¤@¤H¡A¦³°ü¤k«O»Ù¦WÃB)¡A»X¥j¡A¦èÂáAÃäæ¦a°Ï¡A¹´¥Á¡A¾·~¹ÎÅéµ¥¿ï¥X¡AÁ`¦WÃB¨Ì¤H¤fÁ`¼ÆÅÜ°Ê¡C(µù1)

¤¤°ê¤j³°³Q¡u¤¤µØ¤H¥Á¦@©M°ê¡v¦û¾Ú¡A¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¡v¬F©²¾E¥x¤§«á¡AÅãµMµLªk¦A¨Ì¦¹³W©w¿ïÁ|¤¤¥¡¥Á·N¥Nªí¡AµM¦Ó²Ä¤@©¡¥ßªk©e­û¤§¤T¦~¥ô´Á©ó¤@¤E¤­¡³¦~§Y¤w©¡º¡¡C·í®É°ê¥ÁÄÒ¬F©²¥H¥ßªkÅv¤£¯à¤¤Â_¬°¥Ñ¡A±Ä¨ú¨C¦~¥Ñ¦æ¬F°|«Ø½ÐÁ`²Î«t½Ð¥ßªk°|¦P·NÄ~Äò¦æ¨Ï¾Åvªº¤è¦¡¡A¦Û¦æ©µªø¥ô´Á¡C¨ì¤@¤E¤­¥|¦~¡A¥ô´Á¤»¦~ªº°ê¤j¥Nªí©MºÊ¹î©e­û¤]©¡º¡¡C´N°ê¤j¥Nªí³¡¤À¡A·í®É°ê¥ÁÄÒ¬F©²¦Û¦æ¨Ì¾Ëªk²Ä28±ø²Ä2¶µ³W©w¡u¨C©¡°ê¥Á¤j·|¥Nªí¤§¥ô´Á¦Ü¦¸©¡°ê¥Á¤j·|¶}·|¤§¤é¬°¤î¡v«Å§G¡A¥Ñ©ó²Ä¤G©¡°ê¤j¥Nªí¨Æ¹ê¤WµLªk²£¥Í¡A©Ò¥H¤´¥Ñ²Ä¤@©¡¥Nªí¦æ¨Ï¾Åv¡C

³o¨Ç¡uÅv©y±¹¬I¡v³£¥¼¸g¾Ëªkµ{§Ç³B²z¡A¦Ó¥Ñ°õ¬Fªº°ê¥ÁÄÒ¦Û¦æ«Å§G¹ê¦æ¡C´N¥ß©e©MºÊ©e³¡¤À¡A¦b¤@¤E¤­¥|¦~¤~¥Ñ¦æ¬F°|¨ç½Ð¥qªk°|¤jªk©x·|ij¸ÑÄÀ¡A¡u¡K..­È°ê®aµo¥Í­«¤jÅܬG¡A¨Æ¹ê¤W¤£¯à¨Ìªk¿ì²z¦¸©¡¿ïÁ|®É¡A­YÅ¥¥ô¥ßªkºÊ¹î¨â°|¾Åv¤§¦æ¨Ï³´©ó°±¹y¡A«hÅã»P¾Ëªk¾ð¥ß¤­°|¨î«×¤§¥»¦®¬Û¹H¡A¬G¦b²Ä¤G©¡©e­û¥¼¯à¨Ìªk¿ï¥X»P¥l¶°¤§«e¡A¦ÛÀ³¤´¥Ñ²Ä¤@©¡¥ßªk©e­ûºÊ¹î©e­ûÄ~Äò¦æ¨Ï¨ä¾¡v¨Ó³B²z³o­Ó¾Ë¬F°ÝÃD¡C(µù2)

ÀHµÛ®É¶¡ªº®ø³u¡A¤¤¥¡¥Á·N¥Nªí¤]¦]¦Ñ®z¯f¦º¦Ó´î¤Ö¡A²Ä¤@©¡°ê¥Á¤j·|¦b¤@¤E¤»¤»¦~¤T¤ë¤G¤Q¤G¤é²Ä¥|¦¸·|ij­×§ï¡u°Ê­û·`¶Ã®É´ÁÁ{®É±ø´Ú¡v¡A·s¼W¡uÁ`²Î¬°¾AÀ³°Ê­û·`¶Ã»Ý­n¡A±o½Õ¾ã¤¤¥¡¬F©²¤§¦æ¬F¾÷ºc¤Î¤H¨Æ¾÷ºc¡A¨Ã¹ï©ó¨Ìªk¿ïÁ|²£¥Í¤§¤¤¥¡¤½Â¾¤H­û¡A¦]¤H¤f¼W¥[©Î¦]¬G¥X¯Ê¡A¦Ó¯à¼W¿ï©Î¸É¿ï¤§¦Û¥Ñ¦a°Ï¤Î¥ú´_¦a°Ï¡A§¡±o­q¹{¿ìªk¹ê¬I¤§¡v¤§±ø´Ú¡C®Ú¾Ú¦¹¤@±ÂÅv¡A¶à©ó¤@¤E¤»¤E¦~¥Ñ°ê®a¦w¥þ·|ij¨î©w¨Ã¥ÑÁ`²Î¤½§G¹ê¬I¡u°Ê­û·`¶Ã®É´Á¦Û¥Ñ¦a°Ï¤¤¥¡¤½Â¾¤H­û¼W¿ï¸É¿ï¿ìªk¡v¡A¤@¤E¤C¤G¦~¤S¤½¥¬¡u°Ê­û·`¶Ã®É´Á¦Û¥Ñ¦a°Ï¼W¥[¤¤¥¡¥Á·N¥Nªí¦WÃB¿ïÁ|¿ìªk¡v¤Î¡u°Ê­û·`¶Ã®É´Á¹´¿ï¼WÃB¥ßªk©e­û¤ÎºÊ¹î©e­û¿î¿ï¿ìªk¡v¡C

¤@¤E¤E¤@¦~¥|¤ë¤G¤Q¤G¤é¡A¦b¤¤°ê¤j³°©Ò¿ï¥Xªº²Ä¤@©¡°ê¥Á¤j·|²Ä¤G¦¸Á{®É¤j·|¥H¡u¼W­×±ø¤å¡v¤§¤è¦¡§¹¦¨²Ä¤@¦¸­×¾Ë¡A¦P®É¨Ã³q¹L¼o¤î¡u°Ê­û·`¶Ã®É´ÁÁ{®É±ø´Ú¡v¡C¡u¼W­×±ø¤å¡v²Ä¤G±ø­×§ï¾Ëªk­ì¤å²Ä64±ø¦³Ãö¥ßªk©e­û¤§¿ïÁ|¤§³W©w¡A©ú©w¥Ñ¡u¦Û¥Ñ¦a°Ï¡v¿ïÁ|(¨C¬Ù¡Bª½ÁÒ¥«¦U¤G¤H¡A¤H¤f¹O¤G¤Q¸U¤HªÌ¡A¨C¼W¥[¤Q¸U¤H¼W¤@¤H; ¹O¤@¦Ê¸U¤HªÌ¡A¨C¼W¥[¤G¤Q¸U¤H¼W¤@¤H)¡A¼o°£»X¥j©M¦èÂ䧦WÃB¤Î¾·~¹ÎÅ餧¦WÃB¡A·s¼W¥­¦a¤s­M©M¤s¦a¤s­M¦U¤T¤H¡B¹´¥Á¤»¤H¡B©M¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï¤T¤Q¤H¤§¦WÃB¡A¨Ã¦³°ü¤k«O»Ù¦WÃB¤§³W©w¡C²Ä¤G©¡¥ßªk©e­û¤D¨Ì¦¹±ø¤å¤§³W©w¿ïÁ|²£¥Í¡C

¤@¤E¤E¤C¦~¤C¤ë¤Q¤K¤é¡A¥Ñ¡u¦Û¥Ñ¦a°Ï¡v¿ï¥Xªº²Ä¤T©¡°ê¥Á¤j·|²Ä¤G¦¸Á{®É¤j·|§¹¦¨²Ä¥|¦¸­×¾Ë¡A¡u¼W­×±ø¤å¡v²Ä¥|±ø³W©w¦Û²Ä¥|©¡°_(1998¦~©³¿ïÁ|¡B1999¦~°_¥ô)¡A¥ßªk©e­û¦WÃB©T©w¬°225¤H(¡u¦Û¥Ñ¦a°Ï¡vª½ÁÒ¥«¡B¿¤¥«168¦W¡A¨C¿¤¥«¦Ü¤Ö¤@¦W¡A¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï41¤H¡B¹´¥Á8¤H¡B¤Î­ì¦í¥Á8¤H)¡A¨ú¥N²Ä¤@¦¸­×¾Ë¡u¼W­×±ø¤å¡v²Ä¤G±ø¤§³W©w¡C (µù3)

 

¥ßªk©e­ûªº¦WÃB

 

¨Ì·Ó¤@¤E¥|¤C¦~ªº¾Ëªk­ì¤å³W©w¡A¦b¤@¤E¥|¤C¦~À³¿ï¥Xªº²Ä¤@©¡¥ßªk©e­û¬°773¤H¡A¹ê»Ú¿ï¥Xªº¦³760¦W¡A­Y¥H·í®É¥þ°ê¤H¤f¬ù¥|»õ¤C¤d¸U­pºâ¡A¥­§¡¨C¤»¤Q¸U¤H¥H¤W¿ï¥X¤@¦ì¥ßªk©e­û¡C

¡u¤¤µØ¤H¥Á¦@©M°ê¡v¦û¾Ú¤¤°ê¤j³°¡A¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¡v¬F©²¾E¥x¤§«á¡A³\¦h¥ßªk©e­û¨Ã¥¼ÀH¬F©²¨Ó¥x¡A¥[¤W³¡¤À¦Ñ®z¯f¦º¡A¥ßªk©e­ûªº¤H¼Æ´î¤Ö¡A¤@¤E¤»¤E¦~¸É¿ï11¦W¡A¤@¤E¤C¤G¦~¼W¿ï51¦W¡A¤@¤E¤C¤­¦~52¦W¡A¤@¤E¤K¡³¦~97¦W¡A¤@¤E¤K¤T¦~98¦W¡A¤@¤E¤K¤»¦~100¦W¡A¤@¤E¤K¤E¦~130¦W¡C±q¤@¤E¤»¤E¦~¦Ü¤@¤E¤E¤@¦~¶¡¡A¥ßªk©e­ûªº¤H¼Æ§¡¦b150¥H¤U¡C

®Ú¾Ú²Ä¤@¦¸­×¾Ë¼W­×±ø¤å¤§³W©w¡A¤@¤E¤E¤G¦~²Ä¤G©¡¥ßªk©e­û¿ï¥X161¦W(¥]¬A¥xÆW¬Ù87¦W¡A¥x¥_¥«18¦W¡A°ª¶¯¥«12¦W¡AºÖ«Ø¬Ù2¦W¡A¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï30¦W¡B¤s­M6¦W¡B¤Î¹´©~°Ï6¦W)¡C·í®É©Ò¿×¡u¦Û¥Ñ¦a°Ï¡v¤H¤fÁ`¼Æ¬°¤G¤d¤C¤Q¦h¸U¡A¥­§¡¨C¤Q¤G¸U¤K¤d¤H¿ï¥X¤@¦ì¥ß©e¡C¤@¤E¤E¤­¦~²Ä¤T©¡¥ßªk©e­û¦]¤H¤f¼W¥[¿ï¥X164¦W(¨ä¤¤¥xÆW¬Ù¦]¤H¤f¼W¥[¦Ó¼W¥[3¦W¡A¨ä¾l»P²Ä¤G©¡¬Û¦P)¡A·í®É©Ò¿×¡u¦Û¥Ñ¦a°Ï¡v¤H¤fÁ`¼Æ¬°¤G¤d¤@¦Ê¤T¤Q¦h¸U¡A¥­§¡¨C¤Q¤G¸U¤E¤d¤H¿ï¥X¤@¦ì¥ß©e¡C

®Ú¾Ú²Ä¥|¦¸­×¾Ë¼W­×±ø¤å¤§³W©w¡A¤@¤E¤E¤K¦~²Ä¥|©¡¥ßªk©e­û¿ï¥X225¦W(¥]¬A¥xÆW¬Ù135¦W¡A¥x¥_¥«20¦W¡A°ª¶¯¥«11¦W¡AºÖ«Ø¬Ù2¦W¡A¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï41¤H¡B¹´¥Á8¤H¡B¤Î­ì¦í¥Á8¤H)¡A·í®É©Ò¿×¡u¦Û¥Ñ¦a°Ï¡v¤H¤fÁ`¼Æ¬°¤G¤d¤G¦Ê¦h¸U¡A¥­§¡¨C¤E¸U¤C¤d¤H¿ï¥X¤@¦ì¥ß©e¡C(µù4)

°ê·|ij­û®u¦¸»P°ê®a¤H¤f¤§¤ñ²v¡A¦U°ê¤£¦P¡A¦L«×¬ù¬°¤@¦Ê¤G¤Q¤C¸U¤ñ¤@¡A¬ü°ê¬ù¬°¤­¤Q¸U¤ñ¤@¡A«Xù´µ¬ù¬°¤­¤Q¤G¸U¤ñ¤@¡A¤Ú¦è¬ù¬°¤T¤Q¤G¸U¤ñ¤@¡Aµá«ß»«¬ù¬°¤G¤Q¤E¸U¤ñ¤@¡A¤é¥»¬ù¬°¤G¤Q¤­¸U¤ñ¤@¡A­ô­Û¤ñ¨È¬ù¬°¤G¤Q¥|¸U¤ñ¤@¡A®õ°ê¬ù¬°¤Q¤­¸U¤­¤d¤ñ¤@¡Aªü®Ú§Ê¬ù¬°¤Q¥|¸U¤G¤d¤ñ¤@¡A¿D¤j§Q¨È¬ù¬°¤Q¤G¸U¤K¤d¤ñ¤@¡A¼w°ê¬ù¬°¤Q¤G¸U¤­¤d¤ñ¤@¡Aªk°ê¬ù¬°¤Q¸U¤G¤d¤ñ¤@¡A¥[®³¤j¬ù¬°¤Q¸U¤@¤d¤ñ¤@¡A­^°ê¬ù¬°¤K¸U¤K¤d¤ñ¤@¡C(µù5)

¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¥ßªk©e­û¦WÃB»P°ê®a¤H¤f¤§¤ñ²v¡A±q¤j³°®Éªº¤»¤Q¸U¤ñ¤@»¼´î¦Ü¥Ø«eªº¤E¸U¤C¤d¤ñ¤@¡A¨ä¹D²z¦ó¦b¹ê­@¤H´M¨ý¡A¤×¨ä¬O²Ä¥|¦¸­×¾Ë±N¥ßªk©e­û¦WÃB©T©w¬°225¤H¡A¥ç¥¼¨£·í®É­×¾ËªÌ¹ï¦¹¦³¦ó»¡©ú¡A¦ý¾Ú»¡¬O¦]¬°·í®É¤§¥ßªk©e­û¤§¦WÃB¬°164¤H¡A¦]¸Ó¦¸­×¾Ë®É¡A¬Ù¬F©²³Qµê¯Å¤Æ¡A¬Ùij­û¤£¦A¿ïÁ|(¼W­×±ø¤å²Ä¤E±ø)¡A61¦ì¬Ùij­û¦b¥ô´Á©¡º¡«á±N­±Á{¥¢·~¡A¦]¦¹±N¥ßªk©e­û¤§¦WÃB¼W¥[61¦W¡A¦]¦Ó±o¨ì225¤§¼Æ¦r¡CªG¦p¦¹¡A§^¤H¹ê¤£±o¤£¨ØªA·í®É°ê¤j¥Nªí½Ñ¤½ªº³Ð§@¯à¤O¡A¦ý¤]¤£±o¤£»{¬°³oºØºA«×¹ï¾Ë¬F¤§´LÄY¹ê¦³²ö¤j¤§·l¶Ë¡C(µù6)

¥ßªk©e­û¦WÃB»P°ê®a¤H¤f¤§¤ñ²v¨s³º¦p¦ó¤~¾A·í¨ÃµL©w½×¡C¦ý¥Ø«e¤E¸U¤C¤d¤ñ¤@ªº¤ñ²v»P¥L°ê¬Û¤ñÅãµM¹L§C¡A¤]´N¬O»¡¥ßªk©e­û¤§¦WÃB¹L¦h¡C¥Ñ©ó¤H¼Æ¤Ó¦h¡A¨ä¤¤¤£¥FÀݨ¡¥R¼ÆªÌ¡A³o¨ÇÀݨ¡¥R¼Æªº¥ß©eµL¯àµ½ºÉ¥ß©e°Ý¬F¤§³d¡A¬°¨D¦V¿ï¥Áªí²{ª§¨ú³s¥ô¡A¥u¯à¨ì³B°µ¨q¡A¦b¦UºØ´CÅéµo§G¦M¨¥ÁqÅ¥ªº¨¥½×¡A¬Æ¦Ü¦b°ê·|·µ°óÂǪÏÅé©Î§C«Uªº»y¨¥§l¤ÞªÀ·|ªºª`·N¡A°Ý¬F«~½è³Æ¨üªÀ·|¸á¯f¡A¬Æ¦Ü³Q«ü¬°¬OªÀ·|¶Ã·½¡C(µù7)

¨Ì¾Ú¡u¤Ö«hºë¡B¦h«hÀÝ¡v¤§­ì²z¡A·í«e¥ßªk©e­û¤§¦WÃB¤Ó¦h¡A·í¿ï¾÷·|«Ü¤j¡A¦³·N°Ñ¿ï¤§¤H¼Æ¥²¦h¡A¨ä¤¤¦ÛµMÃø§KºUÂø¯À½è¤£¨}¤§¤H¤h¡A¬Æ¦Ü³y¦¨¡u¦H¹ôÅX³v¨}¹ô¡vªº²{¶H¡C¦pªG¦WÃB´î¤Ö¡A¦b¹¬¦hµ°¤Ö¡BÄvª§¿E¯Pªº±¡ªp¤U¡A¿ï¥Á¸û·|ºë¬D²Ó¿ï¡A¯À½è¤£¨}¤§¤H¤hªº·í¿ï¾÷·|¦ÛµM·|´î¤Ö¡A¦]¦¹§Ú­Ì»{¬°¥ßªk©e­û¤§¦WÃB¹ê¦³´î¤Ö¤§¥²­n¡C·íµM¿ïÁ|¨î«×»P¥ßªk©e­û«~½è¤§¿z¿ï¦³·¥¤j¤§Ãö«Y¡A¦¹ÂI¯d«Ý¤U¸`°Q½×¡C

¥ß©eªº¥D­n¤u§@À³¬O±M¤ß©ó¥ßªk°|ùتº°Ý¬F(¦p¼f¬dªk«ß®×¡B¹wºâ®×¡B°ê®a­«¤j¬Fµ¦©MºÊ·þ¬F©²µ¥µ¥)¡A¨ä¤j³¡¤Àªº¤u§@®É¶¡À³ªá¦b¾\Ū¤å¥ó¡B¬ã¨sªk®×©Î¬Fµ¦¡B©M°Ñ¥[¥ßªk°|ªº·|ij¤W¡C¥ß©e¤H¼Æªº¦h¹è©T»Pij¨Æ®Ä²v©M«~½è¨}æÕµL¥²µM¤§Ãö«Y¡A¦ý¤H¼Æ¶V¦h¥ß©e¶V®e©ö¦bij·|ùزV¤ôºN³½¡A¿ï¥Á(©Î°ê·|µûŲ±M·~¹ÎÅé)¤]¸ûÃøµûŲ¥ß©eªº°Ý¬Fªí²{¡C¥Ø«e¦b¥xÆWªº¥ß©eªº¡uªí²{¡v©¹©¹¤£¬O°Ý¬F¡A¦Ó¬O³z¹L¥ßªk°|ªº¡u°ê¨Æ½×¾Â¡v°µ­Ó¤H¨q¡A¥H¦UºØªá©Û(¦p¶K¤j¦r³ø¡Bðã½|¡B³yÁÁ¡B¥´ªo¸Ö¡B°Ûºq¡B±ÀÀ½¡B¥´¸s¬[µ¥µ¥)¦b´CÅé¤WÃn¥ú¡A©M°µ©Ò¿×ªº¡u¿ï¥ÁªA°È¡v¡C

©Î¿×¥ß©e¤H¼Æ¶V¦h¶V¯àªA°È¿ï¥Á¡A¨Æ¹ê¤W¥¿¦n¬Û¤Ï¡C¦b¤H¼Æ¤Ó¦h¡B¤S¯Ê¥F°Ý¬F¯à¤Oªº±¡ªp¤U¡A¥ß©e¬°¨D¿ï²¼±N¤j³¡¤À®É¶¡¥Î©ó©Ò¿×ªº¡uªA°È¿ï¥Á¡v¡A³o¨ÇªA°È³q±`¬O´À¿ï¥Á¡u¶R²¼¡v(¶R¾÷²¼¡B¨®²¼µ¥µ¥)¡A¦V¥qªk¾÷Ãö«OÄÀ¡A¦V¬F©²¾÷ÃöÃö»¡µ¥µ¥¡C³o¨ÇªA°È¥»¬O¿ï¥Áªº»Ý­n­ìµL¥i«p«D¡A¦ý¤£À³¬O¥ß©eªº¥D­n¤u§@¡C³o¨Ç¤u§@À³¥Ñ¬ÛÃö¬F©²¾÷Ãö¨Ó³B²z¡A¥ßªk©e­ûªº¤u§@­«ÂIÀ³¦b¡u¥ßªk©MºÊ·þ¡v¡A¦Ó¤£¦b¡uªA°È¡v¡C¬F©²¹ï¤H¥Á¤§ªA°È¤u§@©y¥Ñ¦æ¬F³¡ªù¾á¥ô¡A¦Ó¤£¬O¥Ñ¥ßªk³¡ªù¾á¥ô¡C¦pªG¥ßªk³¡ªùµ½ºÉ¥ßªk©MºÊ·þ¦æ¬F³¡ªùªº³d¥ô¡A¦æ¬F³¡ªù¹ï¤H¥ÁªA°Èªº«~½è¦ÛµM·|´£°ª¡A¦Ó¤£¬O¥»¥½­Ë¸m¡A±Ë¬F©²¦æ¬F³¡ªù¦Ó¥Ñ¥ßªk³¡ªù¨Ó¾á¥ôªA°È¤u§@¡C§Y¨Ï¦³¥²­n°µ¡u¿ï¥ÁªA°È¡v¤]©y¥Ñ¥ß©e§U²z¨Ó¾á¥ô¡A¦Ó¤£¬O¥ß©e¥»¤H¡C

¦b²Ä¥|¦¸­×¾Ë¤§«e¡A¥ß©e¤H¼Æ¥u¦³160¦h¤H¡A¥Ø«eªº¤H¼Æ¦³225¤H¡A¦ý¥ßªk°|ªº°Ý¬F®Ä²v©M«~½è¤£¼W¤Ï´î¡A¨¬¨£225¤H¬O¶WÃB¡B¬O®ö¶Oªº¡C¡u¤Ñ¤UÂø»x¡v³Ìªñ©Ò°µªº¥Á½ÕÅã¥Ü¡A¥Á¶¡¹ï¥ßªk°|§ï­²ªº´Á¬ß¬Æ®ï¡A¹ï¥ß©e¤H¼Æ¹L¦h¡B°Ý¬F«~½è¤£¨Î¡Bij¨Æ®Ä¯à¤£¹ü¡B¤Î¶Ã¶HÀWÁc¤§²{¶H²`µh´cµ´¡C(µù8) ¥h¦~¤Q¤G¤ë¤@¤é¡A±i¾ÇµÏ¡B¤ý©¯¨kµ¥¦h¦ì¥ß©e¦@¦P¥l¶}¡u¥ßªk°|¶ì¨­¹B°Ê¡v°OªÌ·|¡A«ü¥X·í¥ß©e±j¯P­n¨D¤¤¥¡¬F©²¦æ¬F³¡ªù¤H¨Æ¶O¥Îºë²¡B²Õ´¼h¯Å½G¨­¡B¡u¬F©²¦A³y¡v¤§»Ú¡A¦PÄݤ¤¥¡¬F©²ªº¥ßªk³¡ªù¥çÀ³®Ä¤×¡A¥L­Ì­n¨D¥ß©e¤H¼Æ´î¥b¡A¹w­p¥i´À¬F©²¨C¦~¬Ù¤U¥|¤Q¥|»õ¤¸ªº¸g¶O¡C³o­Ó¸`¬Ù¹ï¤é¯q«úÕuªº°ê®wÀ³¤£µL¤p¸É¡C(µù9)

 

²{¦æ¥ß©e¿ïÁ|¨î«×ªº¯ÊÂI

 

        °£¤F¥ß©e¤H¼Æ¹L¦h·|´î¤Ö¥ß©eªº«~½è¤§¥~¡A¤W­±´£¨ì¡A¿ïÁ|¨î«×»P¥ß©e­Ó¤Hªº¯À½è©M¥ß°|¶°Å骺«~½è¦³±K¤Á¤§Ãö«Y¡C§Ú°ê¥Ø«eªº¿ïÁ|¨î«×±Ä¡u°Ï°ì¡v»P¡u¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï¡vªº²V¦X¨î¡C°Ï°ì¤è­±¦³168®u¡A±Ä¡u¤@°Ï¦h®u¡v(¤SºÙ½Æ¼Æ¿ï°Ï©Î¤¤¿ï°Ï Multiple members constituency)¡B³æ°O«DÅý´ç§ë²¼ªk(Single non-transferable vote, SNTV)¡C¡u¤£¤À°Ï¡v¤è­±¦³57®u¡A±Ä¤@²¼¨î¡A§Y¥H¤À°Ï¤§§ë²¼µ²ªG­pºâ¬FÄÒ©Ò±o¤§®u¦¸¡A¨Ì·Ó¦U¬FÄÒ©Ò´£¥X¤§¦W³æ¨M©w·í¿ï¤H¡A¬FÄÒ¤À®uªùÂe¬°5%¡C(µù10)

        ¦b¥Á¥D°ê®a¤¤¡A§Ú°ê¬O¥Ø«e¥@¬É¤W°ß¤@±Ä¥Î¡u¤@°Ï¦h®u¡vªº¨î«×ªº°ê®a¡C³oºØ¨î«×ªº¯ÊÂI«Ü¦h¡A±`³Q«ü¥Xªº¦³:

        (¤@) ¹ï¤jÄÒ¦³§Q¡A¨Ï¨ä©Ò±o®u¦¸¤ñ²v¤j©ó¨äÁ`±o²¼²v; ¬Û¤Ï¦a¡A¹ï¤pÄÒ¤£§Q¡A¨Ï¨ä©Ò±o®u¦¸¤ñ²v¤p©ó¨äÁ`±o²¼²v¡C(¤G) ¥Ñ©ó¤@°Ï¦h®u¡A´£¦W¤H¼Æ»P°t²¼ºë·Ç¬Û·í­«­n¡A¦b¦¹±¡ªp¤U¡A¿ïÁ|­«¾Ô²¤¦Ó«D¥Á·N¡A¥B¹ï°õ¬FÄÒ¦³§Q¡A¦]¨ä²Õ´¸ûÄY±K¡A´£¦W©Î°t²¼¸û¤Ï¹ïÄҥǿù¤§¾÷·|¸û¤p¡C(¤T) ¥Ñ©ó¤@°Ï¦h®u¡A¬FÄÒ¬°¨D³Ì¤j¤§³Ó§Q¥²´£¦W¦h¤H(µø®u¦ì¦Ó©w)¡A³q±`·|¦bªì¿ï¶¥¬q³y¦¨¿E¯PªºÄvª§¡A§Uªø¬£¨tªº§Î¦¨¡A¦Ó¦b¤j¿ï®É¤]¬O¦U¬FÄÒ¦b²{¦³ªº¥«³õ¦û¦³¶q¤º¤¬¬ÛÄvª§¡A¦Ó«D¬FÄÒ¤§¶¡ªºÄvª§¡C(¥|) ¶R²¼®e©ö´þ¥Í¡A¦]¤@­Ó­Ô¿ï¤H¥u¶·¦b¨ä¿ï°Ï¤ºÀò±o¤@©w¤ñ¨Ò(§Y1/x+1)ªº²¼¼Æ(¤@¯ë¬O¦b5-7%)¡A§Y¥i·í¿ï¡A¦³¤ß¤H®e©ö¦b¦P¤@¤j¿ï°Ï¤º¥|³B¶R²¼¡A¤£©ö¤Þ°_¨ä¥L­Ô¿ï¤Hªºª`·N¡A²¼·½¤£½Ä¬ðªº­Ô¿ï¤H¡A¤]¤£¦b·N¥L¤H¶R²¼¡A§Uªø¸ì¿ï¤§­·¡C(µù11)

        °£¦¹¤§¥~¡A³oºØ¨î«×´N¥ßªk°|ªº«~½è¦Ó¨¥¡A¤]¦³¦p¤Uªº¯ÊÂI:

(¤@) ¦p¤W­z¡A¤@­Ó­Ô¿ï¤H¥u¶·¦b¨ä¿ï°Ï¤ºÀò±o¤@©w¤ñ¨Òªº²¼¼Æ¡A§Y¥i·í¿ï¡A¹L«×±j½Õ­Ó¤Hªº¨¤¦â¡A¬FÄÒ´XµL­«­n©Ê¥i¨¥¡A³y¦¨¥ß°|¬FÄÒÄÒ¬öÃP¦¢¡A¥ß©eµ²ÄÒÀç¨p¡A¦P®É¤]¸û©ö¾É­PµLÄÒÄy¤H¤h¶i¤J¥ßªk°|¡A¤£§Q©ó«Ø¥ß°·¥þªº¬FÄÒ¬FªvÅé¨î¡C(¤G) ¦b¸û¤j(§Y®u¦¸¸û¦h)ªº¿ï°Ï¡A¦]­Ô¿ï¤H¥u¶·¦b¨ä¿ï°Ï¤ºÀò±o¤@©w¤ñ¨Òªº²¼¼Æ¡A¥u­n¦³¤@©wªº¤ä«ù¸s§Y¥i·í¿ï¡A®e©ö²£¥Í¯À½è¤£¨}¡B¯S®í­I´ºªº·í¿ï¤H(¦pª¾¦WÃÀ¤H¡B¶Â¹D¤Hª«¡B°]¹Îª÷¤û¡B¦a¤è¨¤ÀY¡B®a±Ú¶Õ¤Oµ¥µ¥)¡C(¤T) ­Ô¿ï¤H©TµM»P¥LÄÒÄvª§¡A¹ê»Ú¤W»P¥»ÄÒ­Ô¿ï¤H¤§Ävª§¤×¬Æ¡A¿ïÁ|¤§®¦«è±¡¤³±a¤J¥ßªk°|¡A±q¦Ó¼vÅTij¨Æ®Ä²v¡C(¥|) ¥Ñ©ó¤@°Ï¦h®u¡A¥ßªk©e­û­Ó¤H¦b¿ï°Ï¤ºªº¬Fªv³d¥ô¸û¬°¼Ò½k¡A¿ï¥Á¸ûÃøµûŲ¥L­Ì¹ï¿ï°Ï¿ï¥Áªº°^Äm¡C(µù12)

¦Ü©ó¡u¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï¡vªº³]­p¡A¹ï·í®É°õ¬Fªº°ê¥ÁÄÒ¦Ó¨¥¡A¬O¤@½bÂùó窺°µªk¡A¤@¤è­±¥i¹ªÀy¦U¬FÄÒ´£©Þ¥¼¥²¾AÀ³¥xÆW¿ïÁ|¤å¤Æ¡B°]¤O¤£¨¬¡B¯Ê¥F¿ïÁ|©Ê¦Vªº¾ÇªÌ±M®a°Ñ»P¥ßªk¤u§@¡A¥t¤@¤è­±¥iº¡¨¬¨ä©|¦³¥Nªí¡u¦Û¥Ñ¦a°Ï¡v¥H¥~(§Y¤j³°¦a°Ï)ªº¥ßªk©e­ûªºªüQºë¯«¡C(µù13)

§Ú°êªº¡u¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï¡v¥ß©e§Y¬O¡u¬FÄÒ¤ñ¨Ò¥Nªí¨î¡v(Proportional Representation, PR)¡C¬FÄÒ¤ñ¨Ò¥Nªí¨î³Q¥@¬É¦U°ê¼sªx¦a±Ä¥Î¡A¨ä¥\¯à¦b©ó¸Ñ¨M¬FÄÒ±o²¼¼Æ©M©Ò±o®u¦¸§Î¦¨¤ñ¨Ò¤£§¡¿Åªº²{¶H¡A¨Ã¦³§U©ó¬FÄÒ´£¦W®É­ÝÅUªÀ·|¦U¶¥¼hªº¥Nªí©Ê¡A¾A«×«O»Ù°ü¤k©Î®z¶Õ¹ÎÅ骺°Ñ¬FÅv¡A©M´£¨Ñ¾ÇªÌ±M®a°Ñ»P¥ßªk¤u§@¡A´£°ª¥ßªk«~½è¡C±Ä¨ú¥þ­±¬FÄÒ¤ñ¨Ò¥Nªí¨îªº°ê®a¤j³£¦b¼Ú¬w(¦p¥H¦â¦C¡B²üÄõ¡B·ç¤h¡B·ç¨å¡B¶ø¦a§Q¡B¤ñ§Q®É¡B®¿«Â¡B¤¦³Áµ¥¡A¥t¦³¼w°ê§Î¦¡¤W¬O³æ¤@¿ï°Ï»P¬FÄÒ¤ñ¨Ò¥Nªí¨î²V¦X¡A¦ý¹ê»Ú¤W¬O¥þ­±¬FÄÒ¤ñ¨Ò¥Nªí¨î)¡C¦¹ºØ¨î«×¦³«OÅ@¤pÄÒ©M¤Ö¼Æ±Ú¸sªº®ÄªG¡A¦]¦¹±`±`³y¦¨¦hÄÒªºÅé¨î¡A¬F©²ªº²Õ¦¨©¹©¹»Ý­n¬FÄÒÁp¦X¡A¬F§½¤]¦]¦Ó¤£Ã­©w¡C(µù14)

§Ú°êªº¡u¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï¡v¨î«×¦³´X­Ó¯S¦â: ²Ä¤@¡A¥¦¥e¥ß°|Á`®u¦¸©|¤£¤Î¥|¤À¤§¤@(18%)¡C²Ä¤G¡A¥¦±N¥þ°êµø¬°¤@­Ó¿ï°Ï¡A§Y¥H¦U­Ó¬FÄÒ©Ò¦³°Ï°ì­Ô¿ï¤H²Ö­pªº±o²¼Á`¼Æ¬°·Ç¤À°t¡u¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï¡v®u¦ì¡C²Ä¤T¡A¬FÄÒ¤À°t®u¦ìªºªùÂe°¾°ª(5%)¡C²Ä¥|¡A¿ï¥Á¹ï¬FÄÒ©Ò´£¥X¹ï­Ô¿ï¤H¦W³æ²@µL¸m³ñ¤§¦a(§Y©Ò¿×ªº¡u«Ê³¬¦¡¦W³æ¡vClosed list)¡C³o´X­Ó¯S¦â³y¦¨¤U¦C´X­Óµ²ªG:

²Ä¤@¡A¥Ñ©ó©Ò¥eªº¼Æ¶q¤Ó¤Ö¡AµLªk¯u¥¿¹F¨ìÀ±¸É¡u°Ï°ì¥ß©e¡v±o²¼²v»P±o®u²v¤ñ¨Ò©Ê°¾®t(Disproportionality)ªº®ÄªG¡C(µù15) ¥Ñ©ó¸ó¶V¤À®uªùÂe°¾°ª(5%)¡A¥¦¤]¥¼¯à¹F¨ì«O»Ù¤pÄÒ©M¤Ö¼Æ±Ú¸sªº¥Øªº¡C(µù16)

²Ä¤G¡A¿ï¥ÁµLªk®Ú¾Ú¬FÄÒªº´£¦W³æ(¥]¬A­Ô¿ï¤Hªº±ø¥ó©M±Æ¦Wªº¶¶§Ç)ª½±µ¥H¿ï²¼ªí¹F¥ß³õ¡C¦b³oºØ³]­p¤U¡A·í¿ï¥ÁÄÝ·N¬YÄÒªº°Ï°ì­Ô¿ï¤H¡A¦ý¤£º¡·N¸ÓÄÒªº¤£¤À°Ï¦W³æ®É¡A¦p¬O·|¾É­P§ë²¼¤HµL©`¦a§â¿ï²¼§ëµ¹¥L(¦o)³ßÅw©Î¤£³ßÅwªº°Ï°ì­Ô¿ï¤H¡A­°§C¤£¤À°Ï¥ß©eªº¥÷¶q¡B¨¤¦â¡B©M¥\¯à¡A¥B¹ï¬FÄҩΰϰì­Ô¿ï¤H¤£ºÉ¤½¥­¡A¨ÃµLªk±q¿ïÁ|µ²ªG¬Ý¥X¥Á·Nªº¨ú¦V¡C

²Ä¤T¡A°ò©ó¡u¬FÄÒ¦b°Ï°ì¿ïÁ|±o²¼¼Æ¶V°ª¡AÀò¤£¤À°Ï¥ß©e¦WÃB¶V¦h¡vªº­ì²z¡A³oºØ³]­p·¥©ö³y¦¨¬FÄÒ¹L©ó°¾­«°Ï°ì­Ô¿ï¤Hªº´£¦W¡A¦Ó§â¤£¤À°Ï¥ß©e·í°µ¬£¨t§´¨ó©M¹S±eªº¤u¨ã¡A¦Ó¤ÖÅU¼{¨ìªÀ·|¤Î¿ï¥Áªº¤Ï¬M¡C

¥H¤W¬O¨î«×­±ªº¯Ê¥¢¡A¹ê»Ú¹B§@¤W¤S¬O¦p¦ó? §dªF³¥±Ð±Â´N³Ìªñ¤T©¡¥ß©eªº¿ïÁ|©Ò°µªº¬ã¨s±o¨ì´X­Óµ²½×:

(¤@) ¦U¬FÄÒ´£¦Wªº¤£¤À°Ï¥ß©e¤¤¡A¾ÇªÌ±M®a©Ò¦ûªº¤ñ²v¬Æ§C¡A¶È¬OÂIºó©Ê½è¡C(¤G) ±M·~¨ú¦Vªº¤H¤h(¦pÂå¥Í¡B«ß®v¡B¬ì§Þ¤H¤~¡B°]¸g±M®aµ¥µ¥)¥¼¦¨¬°¦U¬FÄÒ´£¦WªºÀu¥ý¦Ò¼{¹ï¶H¡C(¤T) ¨â¤jÄÒ(°ê¥ÁÄÒ©M¥Á¶iÄÒ)´£¦Wªº¤£¤À°Ï¥ß©e¦h¨ã¦a¤è¬£¨t¡B®a±Ú¥ø·~©Î¯S©w°]¹Î¤ä«ùªº­I´º¡A¤×¨ä¬O°ê¥ÁÄÒ¡C¥Á¶iÄÒ´£¦W¤£¤À°Ï¥ß©eÁöµM¤À¬°¬Fªv¡B¾ÇªÌ±M®a¡B©M®z¶Õ¤T²Õ¡A¹ê»Ú¤W³£¦³¿@«pªº¬£¨tÄÝ©Ê¡C(µù17)

 

¥ß©e¿ïÁ|¨î«×ªº§ï­²

 

      ²Ä¤@¦¸­×¾Ë¼W­×±ø¤å²Ä¤G±ø³W©w¡u¦Û¥Ñ¦a°Ï¡v¨C¬Ù¡Bª½ÁÒ¥«¦U¤G¤H¡A¦ý¨ä¤H¤f¹O¤G¤Q¸U¤HªÌ¡A¨C¼W¥[¤Q¸U¤H¼W¤@¤H; ¹O¤@¦Ê¸U¤HªÌ¡A¨C¼W¥[¤G¤Q¸U¤H¼W¤@¤H¡A¥t¦³¹´¥Á¤»¤H¡A¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï¤T¤Q¤H¡C³o¨Ç¼Æ¦r³£µL¾Ç²zªº®Ú¾Ú¡A¤]¤£²Å¦X¡u²¼²¼µ¥­È¡vªº­ì²z¡C²Ä¥|¦¸­×¾Ë¼W­×±ø¤å²Ä¥|±ø±N¥ßªk©e­ûªº¦WÃB©T©w¬°225¤H(¡u¦Û¥Ñ¦a°Ï¡vª½ÁÒ¥«¡B¿¤¥«168¤H¡A­ì¦í¥Á8¤H¡A¹´¥Á8¤H¡A¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï41¤H)«h§¹¥þ¬O¬FªvÅv©y¡A¦P¼Ë¨S¦³¾Ëªk¤W©Î¬Fªv¾Ç¤Wªº­ì²z­ì«h¥i´M¡C

¥ßªk©e­ûªº¦WÃB©TµM¤£¯à¤Ó¤Ö¡A¥H­P¥¢¥h¥Nªí¤H¥Áªº¥\¯à¡C¦ý¬O¦WÃB¤Ó¦h©ö²£¥ÍÀݬò¥R¼Æ¡B®ö¶O°ê®w¡B©Mij¨Æ®Ä²v¤£¹üªº¹úºÝ¡C¿Å½Ñ¥@¬É¥Á¥D°ê®aªº±¡ªp¡A¥H¨C¤G¤Q¸U¤H¤f²£¥Í¤@¦W¥ßªk©e­ûÀ³ÄݦX²z¡C¨Ì¦¹­pºâ¡A¥xÆW²{¦³¤H¤f¬ù¤G¤d¤T¦Ê¸U¡A¥i¦³115¦W¥ßªk©e­û¡A¦¹»P³Ìªñ¦³¨Ç¥ß©e¥D°Êµo°_ªº¡u¥ß©e´î¥b¡vªº¹B°Êªº¼Æ¦r¥©¦X¡C¤£¹L§^¤H»{¬°¡A¥ßªk©e­û¤§¦WÃB¤£©y©T©w¡A¥H­PµLªkÀH¤H¤f¤§¼W¥[¦Ó¥¢¨ä¥Nªí©Ê¡C  

¦b¥ß©e¿ïÁ|¨î«×¤è­±¡A¦h¦~¨Ó°ê¤º¬Fªv¾ÇªÌ¡A¤£°Ý¨ä¬FÄÒÄÝ©Ê¡A¬Ò¥D±i²{¦³¤§¡u°Ï°ì¡v¥ß©e¿ïÁ|±N¡u¤@°Ï¦h®u¡v(½Æ¼Æ¿ï°Ï)§ï¬°¡u¤@°Ï¤@®u¡v(§Y³æ¤@¿ï°Ï Single member constituency)¡A¥H²³æ¦h¼Æ(©ÎºÙ¬Û¹ï¦h¼ÆPlurality)¨M©w³Ó¿ï¡A¤]´N¬O¥Ñ¿ï°Ï±o²¼³Ì°ªªÌ·í¿ï(¤SºÙ¡u¥ý¹£±oÂI¨î¡vFirst past the post)¡C(µù18) ³o¬O¬ü°ê¡B­^°ê¡Bªk°ê¡B¥[®³¤j¡B¿D¤j§Q¨È¡B·s¥[©Yµ¥°ê®a©Ò±Ä¨úªº¨î«×¡C³oºØ¨î«×¦³§Uªø¤jÄÒªºÁͶաA¹ï¥Á·NªºÅܰʬ۷í±Ó·P¡A¥Nij¤h¥²¶·»P¿ï°Ï¿ï¥Á«O«ù±K¤ÁÃö«Y¡A¨ä¬Fªv³d¥ô¬Û·í©ú½T¡C¥t¤@¤è­±¡A³æ¤@¿ï°Ï¨î¹ï¤pÄÒ¤£§Q(¦ý¤£¤@©w¤£§Q©ó¤Ö¼Æ±Ú¸s)¡C¦ý³oºØ¨î«×¥i¥H´î¤Ö¡B¬Æ¦Ü¥h°£¤W­z¡u½Æ¼Æ¿ï°Ï¡vªº¯ÊÂI¡C(µù19)

¬°¤FÀ±¸É³æ¤@¿ï°Ï¨î¹ï¤pÄÒ¤£§Qªº¯ÊÂI¡A¨Ã¥B¬°­ÝÅU¬FÄÒ¤ñ¨Ò¨îªºÀuÂI¡A¦P®É¤]¯à­ÝÅU¾A«×«O»Ù°ü¤k©Î®z¶Õ¹ÎÅé©M´£¨Ñ±M®a¾ÇªÌ°Ñ»P¥ßªk¤u§@¡A§^¤H¥D±i±N¡u¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï¡v¦WÃB´£°ª¡C²{¦æ¾Ëªk¡u¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï¡v©T©w¬°41¤H(¦û¥ß©eÁ`ÃB18%)²@µL¾Ç²zªº®Ú¾Ú¡A¤]§C©ó¥@¬É¦U°ê±Ä¬FÄÒ¤ñ¨Ò¨î°ê®aªº¤ñ¨Ò¡C³o»ò§Cªº¤ñ¨Ò®Ú¥»µLªk¹F¨ì¬FÄÒ¤ñ¨Ò¥Nªí¨îªº¥»¦®¡A¤]µLªk±o¨ì¥¦¹ï¥Á¥Dµo®i©M¬FÄÒ¬Fªvªº¯q³B¡C¦]¦¹§^¤H¥D±i±N¤ñ¨Ò´£°ª¨ìÁ`¼Æªº¤@¥b¡C(µù20)

¦P®É¬°¨Ï¿ï¥Á¯à¦³¾÷·|¿ï¤H©M¿ïÄÒ¡A¨Ã¬°§ïµ½¥Ø«e¤@²¼¨îªº¡u¤£¤À°Ï¡v¥ß©e­p²¼¤À°t¤è¦¡©Ò³y¦¨ªº´£¦W­®²ß©M¹ï¦¹¨î­ì¦®ªº§á¦±¡A©y±N¤@²¼¨î§ï¬°¨â²¼¨î¡A¤@²¼¿ï¡u°Ï°ì¡v¿ï°Ïªº­Ô¿ï¤H¡A¥t¤@²¼¿ï¬FÄÒ©Ò´£¥Xªº¡u¤£¤À°Ï¡v¦W³æ¡C¦P®É¬°¤F¤£¤Ó½ÆÂø³y¦¨¿ï¥Áªº§x´b¡A¦W³æ¥i¥ý±Ä¡u«Ê³¬¦¡¡v¡A¹ê¦æ¤@©Î¨â¦¸¤§«á¦Aµø¨ä®ÄªG¨M©w¬O§_§ï±Ä¡u¶}©ñ¦¡¡v(Open list)¡C(µù21)

¤À°t®u¦¸ªºªùÂe¤£©y¹L§C¡A¥Ø«eªº5%¼È¥iºû«ù¡C(µù22) ¹ê¦æ¨â²¼¨î«á¡A¡u¶W¿ï°Ï¼h¦¸Ä³®u¡v(Additional member system)©Î¡u¸ÉÀv©Êij®u¡v(Supplementary seats system)¡A§^¤H»{¬°±Ä¥Î¤é¥»ªº¡u¨Ã¥ß¨î¡v(Parallel seats)¸û±Ä¥Î¼w°êªº¡uÁp¥ß¨î¡v(bonus seats)¬°§´¡A»\¼w°êªº¡uÁp¥ß¨î¡v·|¦¨¬°¹ê½è¤Wªº§¹¥þ¬FÄÒ¤ñ¨Ò¥Nªí¨î¡C(µù23)

¦p±N¥ß©eÁ`ÃB´î¬°115¤H¡A¡u¤À°Ï¡v»P¡u¤£¤À°Ï¡v¦U¥b¡A«h¡u¤À°Ï¡v±N¬O58®u¡A¡u¤£¤À°Ï¡v±N¬O57®u¡C¹´¥Á±`¦~©~¦í°ê¥~¡A¬J¤£Ãº¯Ç½áµ|¡A¤S¤£¥²¨ü°ê¤ºªk«ß¤§³W½d¡A³]¥ß¹´¥Á¥ß©e¹êÄݵL½]¡AÀ³¤©¼o°£¡C(µù24)

¡u¤À°Ï¡v¤è­±¡A±N¥þ°ê¹º¤À¬°58¿ï°Ï¡A­ì«h¤W¨C¤@¿ï°Ï¬ù¬°¥|¤Q¸U¤H¤f¡C¥Ø«e§Ú°ê¤§¿ï°Ï¥H¦æ¬F°Ï¬°¥»¡A§ï¨î«á¥²­n­«·s¹º¤À¡u¿ïÁ|°Ï¡v(Constituencies)¡C¡u¤£¤À°Ï¡v¤è­±¡A³]¥ß­ì¦í¥Á¡B°ü¤k¡B¤Î®z¶Õ¹ÎÅé«O»Ù¦WÃB¡C¦p¦ó¹º¤À¡u¿ïÁ|°Ï¡v©M­q©w¦UÃþ«O»Ù¦WÃB¬J¬O¤@­Ó«Ü§Þ³N©Ê¡A¤]¬O«Ü¬Fªv©Êªº°ÝÃD¡A½g´T©Ò­­µLªk¦b¦¹¸Ô­z¡A®£»Ý¥t¤å½×­z¡C

 

¿ïÁ|¨î«×§ï­²ªº§xÃø

 

Taagepera ©M Shuggart«ü¥X¡A±q¥Á¥D¨î«×ªºÆ[ÂI¡A¦³¤U¦C±¡ªpªº¿ïÁ|¨î«×¥i¥H¶i¦æ§ï­²: (µù25)

²Ä¤@¡A²{¦³ªº¿ï¨î¤Ó½ÆÂø¡A¨Ï¿ï¥Á¬Ý¤£¥X¨ä°ò¥»ªº¾÷¨î;

²Ä¤G¡A¿ï¥Áªº°¾¦n³Q§á¦±¡A¨Ò¦p¬FÄÒ©ÒÀò±oªº®u¦¸¶W¥X¨ä©ÒÀò±oªº¿ï²¼¡A¬Æ¦Ü©ó¿ï²¼¼W¥[¦Ó®u¦¸¤Ï¦Ó´î¤Ö¡C

²Ä¤T¡A¿ï¨î¹L«×½Æ±Ó·P¡A¤Ö¼Æ¿ï¥Áªº°¾¦nÅÜ°Ê·|³y¦¨®u¦¸ªº¤j´TÅÜ°Ê¡C

²Ä¥|¡A¿ï¨î¹L©ó¿ð¶w¡AµLªk¤Ï¬M¬FÄÒ±o²¼²vªº®t§O¡C

¥xÆW¥Ø«eªº¿ï¨îÁöµM¬O¥@¬É¿W¤@µL¤Gªº¡A¨ä¯ÊÂI¦³¦p¤W­z¡A¦ý¥H¤W¦Cªº¥|­Ó±¡ªp¦Ó¨¥©|¥¼¹F¨ì¤£¥i®e§Ôªº¦a¨B¡A¥xÆWªº¿ï¥Á¹ï¿ï¨î¤]¨S¦³¤Ó¦hªº»{ÃÑ©MÃö¤ß¡A¦]¦¹¨ì¥Ø«e¬°¤î³£ÁÙ¥¼³y¦¨§ï­²¿ï¨îªº±j¤jÀ£¤O¡C§ï­²¤§Án³Ì¥ý­Ë¬O¨Ó¦Û°ê¥ÁÄÒ¡C

°ê¥ÁÄÒÁö¬O¥Ø«e¿ï¨îªºÀò§QªÌ¡A¤£ºÞ¬O±q®u¦¸»P¿ï°Ïªº¤ñ²v¡B²Õ´°t²¼¯à¤O¡B¶R²¼¤è«K¦w¥þµ¥¨¤«×¨Ó¬Ý³£¬O¦p¦¹¡C¦ý¡u½Æ¼Æ¿ï°Ï¡v¿ï¨î©Ò«P¨ÏªºÄÒ¤º¬£¨t¤§ª§¡A¤×¨ä¬O«D¥D¬y»P¦a¤è¬£¨tµ²·ù¤Ï¼³¤¤¥¡¡A«E«ä¤Þ¶i¡u³æ¤@¿ï°Ï¡v¿ï¨î¡A´Á¯à¨ÏÄÒ¤¤¥¡Ä~Äò´x´¤¿ïÁ|´£¦W¡A±±¨îÄÒ­û¡C

¥Á¶iÄÒ¦b¤@¤E¤K¤»¦~¦¨¥ß¤§«áÁöµM¦¨ªø¨³³t¡A¦ý¾ã­Ó¬FÄÒ¦Ó¨¥¤@¦VÁÙ¬O¤pÄҤߺA¡A¬Û«H¦b¥Ø«e¡u½Æ¼Æ¿ï°Ï¡v¿ï¨î¤§¤U¡A¯à¾a»`¶°´åÂ÷²¼¦Ó±o¨ì¤@¨Ç®u¦¸¡A¿ï°Ï®u¦¸¶V¤p¹ï¥¦¶V¤£§Q¡C¦¹¥~¡A¥Á¶iÄÒªº¬Fªv¤Hª«»~¥H¬°¡u³æ¤@¿ï°Ï¡v¿ï¨î§ó®e©ö¶R²¼¡A¦]¦¹¨Ã¤£¤ä«ù¿ï¨î§ï­²¡C

±q°ê¥ÁÄÒ¥X¨«ªº·sÄҩο˥ÁÄÒ¬JµMÁÙ¬O¤pÄÒ¡A¹ï¥Ø«eªº¿ï¨î·íµM»{¬°¹ï¥¦­Ì¦³§Q¡A¦ý¥Ñ©ó¦¹¨âÄÒªº¿ï¥Á³£ÁÙ¶°¤¤¦b¹½·|°Ï©Î²²°Ï¡A¡u³æ¤@¿ï°Ï¡v¤´¯à¤Ï¬M¨ä¹ê¤O¡A¦]¦¹¨Ã¤£±j¯P¤Ï¹ï¤Þ¶i¡u³æ¤@¿ï°Ï¡v¿ï¨î¡C

¿ï¨îªº§ï­²­ì¥»´N¦³®Ú¥»ªº§xÃø¡C¬I¥¿¾W±Ð±Â´¿®Ú¾ÚReeve»PWare ¨â¤Hªº¬ã¨sÂk¯Ç¥X¤CºØ¿ï¨î§ïÅܤ£©öªº­ì¦]: (µù26)

(1)    ¿ï¥Á©Î¬Fªv¤Hª«¹ï¿ï¨î¤£¬Æ¤F¸Ñ;

(2)    ¨ü­­©ó¾Ëªk³W½d¡A¨Ï¿ï¨îªºÅܰʤ£©ö;

(3)    ·Q­n§ó§ï¹CÀ¸³W«hªº¤H¨S¦³¯à¤O¥D¾É;

(4)    ¬J±o§Q¯qªÌ¤£Ä@¦Û¼oªZ¥\;

(5)    ©È¿ï¨î§ï­²·|¦³¹w´Á¤£¨ìªºµ²ªG;

(6)    ©È¹ï¤è±À°Ê¿ï¨î§ï­²·tÂó±¿Ñ¦Ó¤£Ä@¤W·í;

(7)    ¥Ñ©ó¦U¤è¤H°¨¬°¤F¦ÛªÎ¦Ó·QºÉ¿ìªk¨Ï§ï­²¹ï¦Û¤v¦³§Q¡A¨Ã¤FÁקK½Ä¬ð¡A¤j®a³£¤£­n·QÅܰʨî«×¡C

¥H¤W³o¨Ç­ì¦]¤]³£¦s¦b©ó¥xÆW¡A©Ò¥H¥xÆW¿ï¨îªº§ï­²µ´«D©ö¨Æ¡C¤×¨ä¥ßªk°|¿ï¨îªº§ï­²¡A¤£¦ý¯A¤Î¿ïÁ|ªk¥Oªº­×§ï¡A¦Ó¥B¯A¤Î¨ì­×¾Ëªº°ÝÃD¡C²{¦æ¾Ëªk³W©w­×¾Ë­n¥Ñ¥ßªk°|´£Ä³¡A¸g°ê¥Á¤j·|³q¹L¡C¥Ø«e°õ¬Fªº¥Á¶iÄÒ¦b¥ßªk°|©M°ê¥Á¤j·|³£¬O¤Ö¼ÆÄÒ¡C©Ò¥H¦b­×¾Ë©M­×ªk¼h­±¹½¬O·¥¬°§xÃøªº°ÝÃD¡C

¦ý¬O¤@¥¹§ï­²ªºÀ£¤O§Î¦¨¤§«á¤]·|¦³§ï­²ªº«´¾÷¡A­×¾Ë©M­×ªk³£¯àªï¤b¦Ó¸Ñ¡C¬Fªv¾ÇªÌ´¿±q¦U°êªº±¡ªp´M§ä¥X³o¨Ç«´¾÷¡CScarrow©M Thelen/ Steinmo´£¥X¤F¥|ºØ±¡ªp: (1) ¬Fªv©Î¸gÀÙÀô¹Òªº¤jÅÜ°Ê; (2) ¬Fªv¥ÍºAªºÅÜ°Ê; (3) °Ñ»PªÌ(actors)¥ØªºªºÅÜ°Ê; ©M (4) °Ñ»PªÌ¦]¨ä¥LªºÅܰʦӽվã¡C(µù27) Dunleavy /Margetts »{¬°¦b­«¤j¬Fªv¦M¾÷(¦p­²©R¡B¾Ôª§¡B¤º¶Ã¡B¥~±w)¥X²{®É¬O¿ï¨î§ï­²ªº«´¾÷¡C(µù28) Geddes «ü¥X¦b¥Á¥DÂ૬¤§®É¬FªvÅé¨t©M¬FÄÒÅé¨t³£¦³¬Û·í°ªªº¬y°Ê©Ê¡A¤]¬O¨î«×ÅÜ­²ªº«´¾÷¡C(µù29)

¥xÆW¥Ø«eªº±¡ªpÄÝ©ó¤@ºØ­«¤jªº¬Fªv¥ÍºAªº§ïÅÜ¡A°õ¬F¤­¤Q¦h¦~ªº°ê¥ÁÄÒ³Q¥Á¶iÄÒ¨ú¥N¡A¥Á¶iÄÒ·s¤â¤W¥ô·nÂ\¤£©w¡A°ê¥ÁÄÒ­±Á{¥|¤À¤­µõ¡A·sÄÒ©M¿Ë¥ÁÄÒÄÒ©Ê¥¼©w¡A³o¨Ç²{¶H¨Ï¿ï¥Á¹ï¥Ø«eªº¬Fªv©M¸gÀÙÀô¹Ò²£¥Í«Ü¤jªº¤£º¡±¡ºü¡C³oºØ±¡ªp¤]²Å¦X¤W­z¿ï¨î§ï­²ªº«´¾÷¡A¦pªGªÀ·|¤WÃö¤ß°ê®aµo®iªºªÀ¹B¡B¬Fªv¡B©M¾Ç³N¹ÎÅé¯àµ½¥Î¥Á®ð¡A¤j¤O±À°Ê¿ï¨î§ï­²¡A¥¼¥²¨S¦³¹F¦¨¥xÆW¿ï¨î§ï­²ªº§Æ±æ¡C

¡u¥ß©e´î¥b¡vªº¹B°Ê¬O¤@­Ó²³æ©öÀ´ªºÆ[©À©M¤f¸¹¡AµS¦p¤@¤E¤E¡³¦~¥Nªì´Á©Ò´£¥Xªº¡u°ê·|¥þ­±§ï¿ï¡v©M¡uÁ`²Îª½¿ï¡v¤f¸¹¡A©Ò¥H¥¦¬O¤@­Ó±À°Ê¥xÆW¿ï¨î§ï­²«Ü«ê·íªº¤Á¤JÂI¡A§^¤H¥i±q¦¹¶}©l±À°Ê¡C

 

µù¸Ñ

 

1.         ¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¾Ëªk¡v­ì¤å²Ä64±ø¡C

2.         1954¦~1 ¤ë29¤é¤jªk©x·|ij²Ä¤T¤Q¤@¸¹¸ÑÄÀ¡C

3.         ©Ò¿×¡u¦Û¥Ñ¦a°Ï¡v¼W­×±ø¤å¨Ã¥¼ÄÄ©ú¡A¤@¯ë¤F¸Ñ¨t«ü¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¡v¬F©²©Ò²Îªvªº¥xÆW¡B¼ê´ò¡Aª÷ªù¡B©M°¨¯ª¡C

4.         ¥H¤W¼Æ¦r§¡®Ú¾Ú¡u¤¤µØ¥Á°ê¡v¤º¬F³¡²Î­p´£­n¡C

5.         ¥H¤W¼Æ¦r«Y®Ú¾Ú¡u2000 ¥@¬É¦~Ų¡v(¥x¥_: ¤¤¥¡³q°TªÀ¡A1999)¡C

6.         ¥t¦³¤@»¡¬O¡A·í®É°ê¥ÁÄÒ´£Ä³200¤H¡A¥Á¶iÄÒ´£Ä³250¤H¡A·sÄÒ´£Ä³200¤H¡A¦b¤TÄÒ¨ó°Ó«á©w¬°225¤H¡A¦ý¦UÄÒ¹ï©Ò´£¥Xªº¼Æ¥Ø§¡¥¼§@»¡©ú¡C

7.         ³ø³¹´N¦¹ÂI¤§³ø¾É¬Æ¦h¡A¦p¡u·s¥xÆW·s»D©P¥Z¡v²Ä246´Á(2000.12.7-12.13) »P²Ä250´Á(2001.1.7-1.13)¡A¤Î¡u·s·s»D©P¥Z¡v²Ä718´Á(2000.12.7-12.13)¡C

8.         ¡u¤Ñ¤UÂø»x¡v<2001°ê±¡½Õ¬d>¤§¥Á½ÕÅã¥Ü63%¥Á²³¤£«H¥ô¥ß©e¯à¥Nªí¤H¥Á°Ý¬F¡C¡¨½Ö¬O¥xÆWªº¶Ã·½?¡¨ »{¬°¬O¡uªx°ê¥ÁÄÒ¨t¡v¦³33.7%¡A¡u©Ò¦³¥ß©e¡v22.5%¡A¡uªü«óÁ`²Î¡v13.5%¡A¡u´CÅé¡v12.8%¡A¡u¿Ë¥ÁÄÒ¡v11%¡A¡u¥Á¶iÄÒ¡v6.3%¡C  ¡§¦p¦ó¸Ñ¨M¶Ã·½?¡¨ »{¬°¬O¡u¥ß©e´î¥b¡v45.7%¡A¡u¥ß©e³¬¼L¡v18.7%¡A¡u´CÅ鳬¼L¡v14.9%¡A¡u¨î¾Ë¡v10.5%¡A¡u­×¾Ë¡v6%¡A¡u¤¤°ê³¬¼L¡v3.8%¡C

9.         ¡u¤¤°ê®É³ø¡v2000.12.2¡C

10.     °Ñ¾\¡u¤¤¥¡¤½Â¾¤H­û¿ïÁ|ªk¡v¡C

11.     ¦³Ãö¿ïÁ|¨î«×ªº¤¤¡B¥~¤åµÛ§@¬Æ¦h¡A°Ñ¾\¬I¥¿¾W <·í¥N¬Fªv¤ÀªR>²Ä13³¹¡u¿ïÁ|¨î«×¤Î¨ä¼vÅT¡v²Ä139-150­¶ (¥x¥_:«e½Ã¥Xª©ªÀ¡A1998); ¤ý·~¥ß<§Ú°ê¿ïÁ|¨î«×ªº¬Fªv¼vÅT> (¥x¥_:¤­«n¤½¥q¡A1996); §d¤åµ{ <¬FÄÒ»P¿ïÁ|·§½×> (¥x¥_:¤­«n¤½¥q¡A1996); ¹pÄv±Û <¿ïÁ|¨î«×> (¥x¥_: ¬}¹î¥Xª©ªÀ¡A1989); Douglas Rae THE POLITICAL CONSEQUENCES OF ELECTORAL LAWS (Conn.: Yale University Press, 1967); Bernard Grofman and Arend Lijphart, eds. ELECTORAL LAWS AND THEIR POLITICAL CONSEQUENCES (New York: Agathon, 1986); Arend Lijphart and Bernard Grofman, eds. CHOOSING AN ELECTORAL SYSTEMS: ISSUES AND ALTERNATIVES (New York: Praeger, 1984); Rein Taagepera and Mathew S. Shugart, SEATS AND VOTES: THE EFFECTS AND DETERMINANTS OF ELECTORAL SYSTEMS (Conn.: Yale University Press, 1989): Andrew Reeves and Alan Ware, ELECTORAL SYSTEMS: A COMPARATIVE AND THEORETICAL INTRODUCTION (London: Routledge, 1992); David M. Farrell, COMPARING ELECTORAL SYSTEMS (London:Prentice Hall, 1997).

12.     ¤W¦C¤¤¤åµÛ§@¤¤¥ç¦h½Í¤Î¡u½Æ¼Æ¿ï°Ï¡v¦b¥xÆW©Ò³y¦¨¤§¼vÅT¡C

13.     »ô¥ú¸Î´£¥X¡u¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï¡v³]­pªº¨âÂI·N¸q: ¡u¤@¤è­±¹ï°ê®a¥¼²Î¤@¤§¨Æ¹ê¤U¡A¤S¯à­ÝÅU¬ÙÄy¥Nªí©Ê¡A¦³¨ä¬Fªv»ù­È¡C¥t¤@¤è­±¥i§ïµ½¥Á¥D¬Fªv©¹©¹§Î¦¨´I¤H¬Fªvªº¹úºÝ¡A³z¹L¥þ°ê¤£¤À°Ï¥Nªí¥i©ÞÀ¦U­Ó¬FÄÒ¦³¤~µL°]ªºÀu¨qºë­^°Ñ¬F¡v¡C»ô¥ú¸Î <¤¤µØ¥Á°êªº¬Fªvµo®i> (¥x¥_:´­´¼¡A1996)¡A²Ä701­¶¡C

14.     ¦Pµù11¡C

15.     °Ñ¾\ Eric Moon, ¡§Single Non-Transferable Vote Methods in Taiwan in 1996: Effects of an Electoral System,¡¨ ASIAN SURVEY (Vol. 37, No. 7), pp. 652-68.

16.     ¦b¥xÆW¥¿¦¡µù¥Uªº¬FÄÒªñ¤@¦Ê­Ó¡A¦ý¯à¶W¹L¦¹ªùÂeªº¥u¦³¤TÄÒ¡A§Y°ê¥ÁÄÒ¡B¥Á¶iÄÒ¡B©M·sÄÒ¡C¿Ë¥ÁÄÒ©|¥¼¥¿¦¡°Ñ»P¿ïÁ|¡A¦ýÀ³¦³¶W¶VªùÂe¤§¹ê¤O¡C

17.     §dªF³¥ ¡u§Ú°ê¥ßªk°|¤£¤À°Ï©e­û¨î«×¤§¬ã¨s¡v<¿ïÁ|¬ã¨s> (²Ä¤»¨÷²Ä¤@´Á²Ä143-174­¶¡C

18.     ¤@¤E¤E¤»¦~¤Q¤G¤ëªº¡u°ê®aµo®i·|ij¡v¤]¦³¦p¦¹ªº¦@ÃÑ:¡u¦¨¥ß¸óÄÒ¬£¤p²Õ¬ãij¤¤¥¡¥Á·N¥Nªí¿ïÁ|¨î«×±Ä³æ¤@¿ï°Ï¨î»P¤ñ¨Ò¥Nªí¨î¤GªÌ²V¦Xªº¨â²¼¨î¤§¨ãÅ餺®e¡v¡C

19.     ¦Pµù11¡C

20.     ¦U°ê¤§¬FÄÒ¤ñ¨Ò¥Nªí¨î¤§¤ñ²v¦p¤U: «nÁú25%¡A¸q¤j§Q25%¡A¤é¥»40%¡A¯Ã¦èÄõ47%¡A¼w°ê50%¡A«Xù´µ50%¡C°Ñ¾\¬I¥¿¾W(¦Pµù11)¡A²Ä142­¶¡C

21.     ©Ò¿×¡u«Ê³¬¦¡¡v¬O«ü¿ï¥Á¥u¯à§ë²¼µ¹¦U­Ó¬FÄÒ¡A¤£¯à¦b¦U¬FÄÒªº¦W³æ¤¤¿ï¾Ü¦U§Oªº­Ô¿ï¤H¡C©Ò¿×¡u¶}©ñ¦¡¡v¬O«ü¿ï¥Á¯à¦b¦U­Ó¬FÄÒ¦W³æ¤¤¡A¬Æ¦Ü¤£¦P¬FÄÒ¦W³æ¤¤¬D¿ï¤@¦ì©Î¦h¦ì­Ô¿ï¤H¡C

22.     ¦U°êªùÂe¤§³W©w¦p¤U: ¼w°ê5% ©Î¤À°Ï±o¤T®u¥H¤W¡A¯Ã¦èÄõ5%©Î¤À°Ï±o¤@®u¥H¤W¡A«nÁú¤À°Ï±o¤­®u¥H¤W¡A¤é¥»2%©Î¤À°Ï±o¤G®u¥H¤W¡A¸q¤j§Q4%¡A¦I¤ú§Q5%¡A«Xù´µ5%¡C°Ñ¾\¤ý·~¥ß(¦Pµù11)¡A²Ä42­¶¡C

23.     ©Ò¿×¡u¶W¿ï°Ï¼h¦¸Ä³®u¡v(Additional member system)¬O«ü¦U¿ï°Ï¤¤¦]¬FÄÒ±o²¼¥¼¹F·í¿ï°ò¼Æ¦Ó³Ñ¾lªº®u¦¸¡C©Ò¿×¡u¸ÉÀv©Êij®u¡v(Supplementary seats system)¬O«ü¦b¦U¿ï°ÏÀ³¿ï¦WÃB¤§¥~¡A¦b§ó¤j°Ï°ì©Î¥þ°ê¬°½d³ò©Ò³]¥ßªº®u¦¸¡A¥H¥­¿Å¦b¿ï°Ï¤¤¥i¯à¥X²{ªº¡u¤ñ¨Ò©Ê°¾®t¡v¡C¡uÁp¥ß¨î¡v¬O¥H¦U¬FÄÒªºÁ`±o²¼²v¬°·Ç¡A¨Ó¨M©w¦U¬FÄÒÀ³±oªºÁ`®u¦¸¡C¡u¨Ã¥ß¨î¡v¬O¦U¬FÄҨ̨ä¬FÄÒ±o²¼²v¨Ó¤À°t¤£¤À°Ïªº¦WÃB¡A»P¦U¬FÄÒ¦b°Ï°ì¤¤¤w·í¿ïªº®u¦¸¦h¹èµLÃö¡C

24.     ¥@¬É¦U°ê¤§¨Ò¡A¤¹³\¹´¥Á§ë²¼ªÌ¦³¤§¡A¦ýµL¹´¥Á°ê·|ij­û¡C

25.     Taagepera and Shugart, ¦Pµù11¡C

26.     °Ñ¾\¬I¥¿¾W¡u¿ïÁ|¨î«×¿³­²ªº·§©À¬[ºc¡v<¥xÆW¬Fªv«Øºc> (¥x¥_: «e½Ã¡A1999)¡A²Ä204­¶; Reeve and Ware (¦Pµù11); Pippa Norris, ¡§Choosing Electoral Systems: Proportional, Majoritarian and Mixed Systems,¡¨ INTERNATIONAL POLITICAL SCIENCE REVIEW (Vol. 16, No. 1), pp. 3-8¡C

27.     Susan Scarrow, ¡§Party Competition and Institutional Change: The Expansion of Direct Democracy in Germany,¡¨ PARTY POLITICS (Vol. 3, No. 4), pp. 451-72; Kathleen Thelen and Sven Steinmo, ¡§Historical Institutionalism in Comparative Politics,¡¨ in S. Steinmo, K. Thelen and Frank Longstreth, eds. STRUCTURING POLITICS: HISTORICAL INSTITUTIONALISM IN COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1992)¡C

28.     Patrick Dunleavy and Helen Margetts, ¡§Understanding the Dynamics of Electoral Reform,¡¨ INTERNATIONAL POLITICAL SCIENCE REVIEW (Vol. 16, No. 1), pp. 9-29¡C

29.     Baraba Geddes, ¡§Initiation of New Democratic Institutions in Eastern Europe and Latin America,¡¨ in Arend Lijphart and Carlos Waisman, eds. INSTITUTIONAL DESIGN IN NEW DEMOCRACIES: EUROPE AND LATIN AMERICA (Colo.: Westview Press, 1996), pp. 15-41¡C